Do you know the difference between an Ash tree and a lookalike? Many trees are often mistaken for Ash trees but, with a closer look, it’s easy to tell them apart.
In this article, we’ll explore the characteristics of the three main species of Ash trees, White Ash, Green Ash, and Pumpkin Ash, as well as look at the distinguishing features of common Ash tree lookalikes like the Boxelder, Hickory, and Mountain Ash.
Discover the differences between these trees and find out what trees are mistaken for Ash trees.
Table of Contents
Short Answer
There are a few trees that can be mistaken for ash trees.
These include boxelder, which has compound leaves and winged seeds, white fringe tree, which has compound leaves and white flowers, and green ash, which has pinnately compound leaves.
All three of these trees have similar characteristics to ash trees, so it is easy to understand how they could be mistaken for them.
Identifying Ash Trees
Identifying ash trees can be a difficult task, especially when one is trying to differentiate between different species of ash.
However, with the right knowledge, one can easily tell the difference between ash and other trees.
The key identifying factors for ash trees are the type of leaves, bark, seeds, and growth patterns.
When it comes to leaves, ash trees typically have opposite, compound leaves with five to nine leaflets.
Most ash trees also have a pair of very small leaflets at the end of each leaf.
The bark of ash trees tends to be grayish and smooth when young, but becomes more furrowed and scaly as the tree matures.
The seeds of ash trees are small, winged samaras that are typically paired together.
They have a distinctive shape that is often mistaken for maple tree seeds.
Ash tree growth is typically fast and straight, with light gray-green foliage that turns yellow in the fall.
In addition to the common ash species, there are several other trees that are often mistaken for ash trees.
These include boxelder, hickory, and mountain ash.
Boxelder is similar to ash in that it has compound leaves, but differs in that its bark is much darker and more deeply furrowed.
Hickory and mountain ash also have similar features to ash trees, but hickory has a much more distinctive bark pattern and mountain ash leaves are much more feather-like in shape.
When it comes to properly identifying an ash tree, it is important to take into consideration all of the above features.
It is also important to note that not all ash trees are the same, and some species may display slightly different characteristics.
By carefully examining all the different features of an ash tree, one can easily tell the difference between it and other tree species.
White Ash Tree Characteristics
White ash trees (Fraxinus americana) are among the most widely distributed ash species in North America and are known for their distinctive, diamond-shaped leaves and smooth, gray bark.
The leaves of these trees can range from light green to dark green and have a serrated edge with five to nine pointed lobes.
White ash trees typically have a rounded crown and can reach heights of up to 80 feet with a spread of about 40 feet.
The bark of white ash trees can be smooth and gray when young, but it tends to become more ridged and furrowed as the tree matures.
These trees also have an “opposite branching” structure, meaning that the branches grow out in pairs directly across from each other.
White ash trees are also known to produce unique, winged seeds called “samaras” in the spring.
These samaras are a key distinguishing feature of white ash trees and can help to differentiate them from other species.
Green Ash Tree Characteristics
The green ash tree (Fraxinus pennsylvanica) is one of the most commonly mistaken trees for the white ash and pumpkin ash.
It is native to North America and is found in many parts of the United States and Canada.
Green ash trees are typically found near rivers and streams, and can also be found in wet areas such as swamps and bottomland forests.
Green ash trees can grow to a height of between 40 and 70 feet, and can spread out to a diameter of up to 40 feet.
The bark of the green ash tree is greyish-brown in color and can be scaly or furrowed.
The leaves of the green ash tree are compound, meaning they are made up of several leaflets.
The leaflets are usually 5 to 9 inches long and are green on top and lighter green on the bottom.
The leaves are also slightly serrated and have a pointed tip.
The green ash tree produces small, greenish-yellow flowers in the spring.
The flowers are arranged in loose clusters and are followed by small, winged fruits, which turn a dark brown color in the fall.
The fruits of the green ash tree are an important source of food for many species of birds and mammals.
Green ash trees are a popular choice for landscaping because of their fast growth rate, tolerance to drought and pollution, and attractive foliage.
They are also widely used as a windbreak or shade tree in urban areas.
Green ash trees are relatively easy to identify due to their unique characteristics, but can easily be mistaken for white ash or pumpkin ash trees.
Pumpkin Ash Tree Characteristics
The pumpkin ash tree (Fraxinus profunda) is a tall, deciduous tree native to North America, growing up to 80 feet in height and spreading up to 40 feet.
Its bark is dark gray and scaly and its leaves are alternate, pinnately compound, and dark green in color.
The leaves usually have 5 to 9 leaflets and are up to 8 inches in length.
In the fall, the leaves take on a bright yellow hue.
The pumpkin ash tree also produces small, pale green flowers and papery, winged samaras.
It prefers moist, well-drained soils and full sun, but can tolerate a variety of soil conditions.
It is a popular choice for shade and ornamental landscaping.
Common Ash Tree Lookalikes
When it comes to trees, there are many that look similar in terms of leaves, bark, and other characteristics.
This can make it difficult to tell the difference between one tree and another, especially when it comes to ash trees.
Ash trees are part of the Fraxinus genus, and include white ash, green ash, and pumpkin ash.
But, there are several other trees that can easily be mistaken for ash trees.
The most common tree lookalikes for ash trees are boxelder, hickory, and mountain ash.
All three of these trees share similar characteristics with ash trees, such as serrated leaves and similar bark.
However, there are some subtle differences that can help distinguish one tree from another.
Boxelder trees have a smooth, grey bark, while hickory trees have a dark, scaly bark.
Mountain ash trees have a smooth, reddish-brown bark that can easily be mistaken for an ash tree.
Furthermore, boxelder trees have a compound leaf structure, while hickory and mountain ash trees have a simple leaf structure.
These differences in bark and leaf structure can help distinguish one tree from another, but there are still several other characteristics that can help identify an ash tree.
Ash trees have a straight, conical crown shape, while boxelder trees have a rounded, spreading crown.
Hickory and mountain ash trees have a rounded crown, but the leaves of hickory trees are longer and wider than those of mountain ash trees.
Additionally, the seeds of ash trees are small and winged, while the seeds of boxelder, hickory, and mountain ash trees are larger and wingless.
By taking all of these characteristics into account, it is possible to properly identify an ash tree.
It is important to correctly identify an ash tree before attempting to treat or remove it, as the wrong tree may be targeted.
Knowing the differences between ash trees and their lookalikes can help you ensure that you are targeting the correct tree.
Boxelder Characteristics
Boxelder (Acer negundo) is often mistaken for an ash tree due to its similar shape and compound leaves.
However, it is actually a type of maple and not an ash tree.
Boxelders are typically found in North America and can be identified by their compound leaves with three to seven leaflets.
The leaflets are usually oval with serrated edges.
Boxelder bark is gray-brown and scaly, with shallow furrows that make it look diamond-shaped.
The twigs of a boxelder tree are usually green and smooth, but may have some corky ridges and black lenticels.
The fruit of a boxelder is a two-winged samara, which is a type of seed pod.
Boxelder trees can often be mistaken for ash trees due to their similar shape and leaves, but the bark and fruit can help with identification.
Hickory Characteristics
Hickory trees are members of the genus Carya, and are not related to ash trees in the Fraxinus genus.
However, they are often mistaken for ash trees due to similarities in their leaves and bark.
Hickory trees have compound leaves, meaning each leaf is composed of several leaflets.
The leaflets are oval-shaped with a slightly serrated edge and a pointed tip.
The bark of hickory trees is usually dark gray and deeply furrowed, giving it a shaggy texture.
The bark of young hickory trees is smoother and more gray in color.
The wood of hickory trees is hard and strong, making it a popular choice for furniture and tool handles.
Additionally, hickory trees produce small nuts that are edible and can be used in cooking.
Mountain Ash Characteristics
Mountain ash trees (Sorbus spp.), while not actually ash trees, are often mistaken for ash due to similarities in leaf shape and bark.
Mountain ash trees have a compound leaf structure, meaning each leaf is made up of multiple leaflets.
The leaflets have a serrated or jagged edge, similar to white ash, but are often less deeply divided than other ash species.
Mountain ash trees also have a smooth bark that is gray to brownish in color, sometimes with a slightly orange hue.
The bark may have prominent ridges or furrows, giving it a diamond pattern.
The bark may also have a slightly scaly texture.
Unlike ash trees, mountain ash trees have red berries that remain on the tree throughout the winter months.
These berries are a food source for birds and other wildlife.
Final Thoughts
Knowing the key differences between ash trees and their lookalikes is important when it comes to treating or removing them.
While white, green, and pumpkin ash trees are all members of the Fraxinus genus, their characteristics can vary greatly.
Boxelder, hickory, and mountain ash trees can also be mistaken for ash trees, and may require closer examination.
With the information provided in this article, you should be able to confidently identify the various ash trees and lookalikes in your area.